Securities And Exchange Commission Announces Approval Of 11 Bitcoin ETF Applications And What It Means

The U.S. securities regulator made a significant decision on Wednesday, granting approval for the first U.S.-listed exchange traded funds (ETFs) designed to track bitcoin. This marks a watershed moment for the world's largest cryptocurrency and the broader crypto industry. The Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) announced its approval of 11 applications, including those from prominent names such as BlackRock, Ark Investments, and Fidelity. Despite warnings from some officials and investor advocates about associated risks, the products are set to commence trading on Thursday, initiating a competitive race for market share among issuers.

A culmination of a decade-long effort, these ETFs represent a game-changing development for bitcoin, enabling investors to gain exposure to the cryptocurrency without direct ownership. This approval provides a significant boost for the crypto industry, which has been marred by scandals in recent years. Andrew Bond, Managing Director and Senior Fintech Analyst at Rosenblatt Securities, hailed the decision as a monumental step towards the institutionalization of bitcoin as an asset class. Analysts at Standard Chartered anticipate significant inflows of $50 billion to $100 billion this year alone, while others project approximately $55 billion over the next five years.
With bitcoin's market capitalization surpassing $913 billion as of Wednesday, according to CoinGecko, and U.S. ETF net assets totaling $6.5 trillion as of December 2022, the potential impact of these ETFs is considerable. The cryptocurrency's recent surge, climbing over 70% in anticipation of the ETF approval and reaching its highest level since March 2022, further underscores the market's anticipation and optimism surrounding these developments.

The success of these ETFs in attracting investor inflows will largely hinge on factors such as fees and liquidity. Some issuers have adjusted their proposed fees, with BlackRock and Ark/21Shares among those slashing fees or offering fee waivers for a limited time. Liquidity, particularly for short-term speculators, is also expected to play a significant role in determining the popularity of these products.
In anticipation of the launch, companies are gearing up for vigorous online advertising and marketing campaigns. Despite some logistical challenges, including an unauthorized social media post falsely claiming SEC approval and a brief confusion surrounding the regulatory announcement, the industry remains buoyant. Grayscale CEO Michael Sonnenshein expressed enthusiasm for the democratization of bitcoin access, while Douglas Yones, Head of Exchange Traded Products at the New York Stock Exchange, hailed the approval as a milestone for the ETF industry. Cynthia Lo Bessette, Head of Digital Asset Management at Fidelity, welcomed the introduction of new products, providing investors with increased choices for engaging with crypto assets.

Regulatory experts believe that the approval of bitcoin ETFs could pave the way for further innovation in the crypto space. With several issuers already exploring ETFs tracking other cryptocurrencies, the landscape of crypto investment opportunities may continue to evolve. Georgetown's McDonough School of Business Associate Professor Jim Angel highlighted the significance of this moment, suggesting that the SEC's approach to crypto regulation may undergo a shift following this landmark decision.
​
Despite the regulatory green light from the SEC, concerns persist regarding investor protection and the legitimacy of bitcoin as an asset class. SEC Chair Gary Gensler, known for his skepticism towards crypto, emphasized the speculative and volatile nature of bitcoin, as well as its association with criminal activities. Notably, Gensler, alongside two Republican commissioners, voted in favor of approving the ETFs, while the agency's two Democratic commissioners dissented. This bipartisan decision reflects a departure from the SEC's previous stance on bitcoin ETFs, which had been rejected due to concerns about market manipulation.

In light of a federal appeals court ruling last year and mounting pressure for regulatory clarity, the SEC's decision to approve bitcoin ETFs signals a significant shift in its approach to crypto assets. However, the agency maintains its vigilance against illicit activities and emphasizes that the approval does not signify a relaxation of its enforcement efforts.

To address concerns about market manipulation, several exchanges had initially proposed collaboration with Coinbase to monitor trading activity. However, issuers ultimately opted for an existing partnership with the Chicago Mercantile Exchange, a pivotal player in Grayscale's legal victory. Unfortunately, the SEC's ongoing lawsuit against Coinbase underscores the regulatory scrutiny facing major players in the crypto industry.

Despite the approval, skepticism persists among some investor advocacy groups, who warn of the continued vulnerability of bitcoin to fraudulent activities. Dennis Kelleher, CEO of Better Markets, labeled the SEC's decision a "historic mistake," arguing that bitcoin and crypto assets lack legitimate utility and remain susceptible to fraud.